*By Michal Jagodzinski - Work Log - April 7th, 2023*

Welcome back to Star Coffee! In this Satellite Analysis Toolkit work log I discuss the future design of the SAT system and implement some more orbital dynamics. Let's get into it.

I am thinking of implementing a universal `Satellite`

object with functionality throughout SAT. For example, you can design a mission for a `Satellite`

in MissionPlanner, analyze the ground tracks of its orbits in GroundTracker, etc. This would also allow for saving and sharing analyses.

I will probably also define a `Mission`

struct in order to define the state of a `Satellite`

at a given stage in its lifetime. Each `Satellite`

would have one or more `Mission`

structs to define the entire long-term mission of that specific satellite.

In general I want to make use of `structs`

to try and create more of a 'coherent' system. When working with SAT, I don't want to have to memorize the inner workings of the code. I want to develop a nice, high-level interface to work with.

This scenario is the same as the two-body problem except with the introduction of another body that gravitationally influences the two others, and is in turn influenced by the others. The differential equations for the three-body problem are defined as:

$\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_{1} = \begin{bmatrix} \ddot{x}_{1} \\ \ddot{y}_{1} \\ \ddot{z}_{1} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \dfrac{G m_{2} (x_{2} - x_{1})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (x_{3} - x_{1})}{r_{13}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{2} (y_{2} - y_{1})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (y_{3} - y_{1})}{r_{13}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{2} (z_{2} - z_{1})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (z_{3} - z_{1})}{r_{13}^3} \end{bmatrix}$ $\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_{2} = \begin{bmatrix} \ddot{x}_{2} \\ \ddot{y}_{2} \\ \ddot{z}_{2} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \dfrac{G m_{1} (x_{1} - x_{2})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (x_{3} - x_{2})}{r_{3}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{1} (y_{1} - y_{2})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (y_{3} - y_{2})}{r_{23}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{1} (z_{1} - z_{2})}{r_{12}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{3} (z_{3} - z_{2})}{r_{23}^3} \end{bmatrix}$ $\ddot{\mathbf{r}}_{3} = \begin{bmatrix} \ddot{x}_{3} \\ \ddot{y}_{3} \\ \ddot{z}_{3} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \dfrac{G m_{1} (x_{1} - x_{3})}{r_{13}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{2} (x_{2} - x_{3})}{r_{23}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{1} (y_{1} - y_{3})}{r_{13}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{2} (y_{2} - y_{3})}{r_{23}^3} \\ \dfrac{G m_{1} (z_{1} - z_{3})}{r_{13}^3} + \dfrac{G m_{2} (z_{2} - z_{3})}{r_{23}^3} \end{bmatrix}$Where

$\begin{align*} r_{12} &= \sqrt{ (x_{2} - x_{1})^2 + (y_{2} - y_{1})^2 + (z_{2} - z_{1})^2 } \\ r_{13} &= \sqrt{ (x_{3} - x_{1})^2 + (y_{3}-y_{1})^2 + (z_{3}-z_{1})^2 } \\ r_{23} &= \sqrt{ (x_{3} - x_{2})^2 + (y_{3}-y_{2})^2 + (z_{3}-z_{2})^2 } \end{align*}$The implementation of this system in Julia is similar to the two-body problem, so see my previous post if you want some more details. Starting off with the required libraries and a helper function:

```
using Plots, ModelingToolkit, DifferentialEquations, Unitful
function remove_units(p::Dict)
Dict(k => Unitful.ustrip(ModelingToolkit.get_unit(k), v) for (k, v) in p)
end
```

Next, the variables and parameters of the system:

```
@variables(begin
t, [unit=u"s"],
x₁(t), [unit=u"m"],
y₁(t), [unit=u"m"],
z₁(t), [unit=u"m"],
ẋ₁(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ẏ₁(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ż₁(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
x₂(t), [unit=u"m"],
y₂(t), [unit=u"m"],
z₂(t), [unit=u"m"],
ẋ₂(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ẏ₂(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ż₂(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
x₃(t), [unit=u"m"],
y₃(t), [unit=u"m"],
z₃(t), [unit=u"m"],
ẋ₃(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ẏ₃(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
ż₃(t), [unit=u"m/s"],
r₁₂(t), [unit=u"m"],
r₁₃(t), [unit=u"m"],
r₂₃(t), [unit=u"m"]
end)
D = Differential(t)
@parameters G [unit=u"N*m^2/kg^2"] m₁ [unit=u"kg"] m₂ [unit=u"kg"] m₃ [unit=u"kg"]
```

Next, the equations of the system:

```
three_body_equations = [
r₁₂ ~ sqrt((x₂ - x₁)^2 + (y₂ - y₁)^2 + (z₂ - z₁)^2),
r₁₃ ~ sqrt((x₃ - x₁)^2 + (y₃ - y₁)^2 + (z₃ - z₁)^2),
r₂₃ ~ sqrt((x₃ - x₂)^2 + (y₃ - y₂)^2 + (z₃ - z₂)^2),
D(x₁) ~ ẋ₁,
D(y₁) ~ ẏ₁,
D(z₁) ~ ż₁,
D(ẋ₁) ~ G*m₂*(x₂ - x₁)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(x₃ - x₁)/r₁₃^3,
D(ẏ₁) ~ G*m₂*(y₂ - y₁)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(y₃ - y₁)/r₁₃^3,
D(ż₁) ~ G*m₂*(z₂ - z₁)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(z₃ - z₁)/r₁₃^3,
D(x₂) ~ ẋ₂,
D(y₂) ~ ẏ₂,
D(z₂) ~ ż₂,
D(ẋ₂) ~ G*m₁*(x₁ - x₂)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(x₃ - x₂)/r₂₃^3,
D(ẏ₂) ~ G*m₁*(y₁ - y₂)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(y₃ - y₂)/r₂₃^3,
D(ż₂) ~ G*m₁*(z₁ - z₂)/r₁₂^3 + G*m₃*(z₃ - z₂)/r₂₃^3,
D(x₃) ~ ẋ₃,
D(y₃) ~ ẏ₃,
D(z₃) ~ ż₃,
D(ẋ₃) ~ G*m₁*(x₁ - x₃)/r₁₃^3 + G*m₂*(x₂ - x₃)/r₂₃^3,
D(ẏ₃) ~ G*m₁*(y₁ - y₃)/r₁₃^3 + G*m₂*(y₂ - y₃)/r₂₃^3,
D(ż₃) ~ G*m₁*(z₁ - z₃)/r₁₃^3 + G*m₂*(z₂ - z₃)/r₂₃^3,
]
diffeq_three_body_system = ODESystem(
three_body_equations,
t,
name=:three_body_system
) |> structural_simplify
```

Example initial conditions:

```
u₀ = Dict(
x₁ => -0.97138u"m",
y₁ => 0.0u"m",
z₁ => 0.0u"m",
ẋ₁ => 0.0u"m/s",
ẏ₁ => -1.37584u"m/s",
ż₁ => 0.0u"m/s",
x₂ => 1.0u"m",
y₂ => 0.0u"m",
z₂ => 0.0u"m",
ẋ₂ => 0.0u"m/s",
ẏ₂ => -0.34528u"m/s",
ż₂ => 0.0u"m/s",
x₃ => 0.0u"m",
y₃ => 0.0u"m",
z₃ => 0.0u"m",
ẋ₃ => 0.0u"m/s",
ẏ₃ => 1.519362144u"m/s",
ż₃ => 0.0u"m/s",
)
p = Dict(
G => 1.0u"N*m^2/kg^2",
m₁ => 0.5312u"kg",
m₂ => 2.2837u"kg",
m₃ => 1u"kg"
)
```

Finally, defining the problem and solving:

```
three_body_problem = ODEProblem(
diffeq_three_body_system,
remove_units(u₀),
[0.0, 10.0],
remove_units(p),
jac=true
)
three_body_sol = solve(three_body_problem, Vern7())
```

Plotting the results:

```
interp = three_body_sol(0.0:0.001:10.0)
plot(interp[x₁], interp[y₁], interp[z₁], size=(600,500), dpi=300)
plot!(interp[x₂], interp[y₂], interp[z₂])
plot!(interp[x₃], interp[y₃], interp[z₃])
```

Next, a special case of the three-body problem. The circular restricted three-body system is the case when two bodies $m_1$ and $m_2$ orbiting each-other at a constant distance $r_{12}$, with a significantly smaller mass moving throughout this system. A real-life example of this is the Earth-Moon system with a satellite moving throughout it. This case of the three-body problem is useful when analyzing missions that transfer between the Earth and the Moon.

The differential equations describing the movement of the smaller mass/satellite are:

$\begin{align*} \ddot{x} &= 2 \Omega \dot{y} + \Omega^2 x - \frac{\mu_{1}}{r_{1}^3}(x + \pi_{2} r_{12}) - \frac{\mu_{2}}{r_{2}^3}(x - \pi_{1}r_{12}) \\ \ddot{y} &= \Omega^2 y - 2 \Omega \dot{x} - \frac{\mu_{1}}{r_{1}^3}y - \frac{\mu_{2}}{r_{2}^3}y \\ \ddot{z} &= -\frac{\mu_{1}}{r_{1}^3}z - \frac{\mu_{2}}{r_{2}^3}z \end{align*}$Where

$\begin{align*} \Omega &= \sqrt{ \dfrac{G(m_{1} + m_{2})}{r_{12}^3} } \\ \mu_{1} &= G m_{1} \\ \mu_{2} &= G m2 \\ \pi_{1} &= \frac{m_{1}}{m_{1}+m_{2}} \\ \pi_{2} &= \frac{m_{2}}{m_{1}+m_{2}} \\ r_{1} &= \sqrt{ (x + \pi_{2}r_{12})^2 + y^2 + z^2 } \\ r_{2} &= \sqrt{ (x - \pi_{1}r_{12})^2 + y^2 + z^2 } \end{align*}$For the CR3BP, I will be implementing the Earth-Moon system, however the system can be parameterized to model any arbitrary system. First, defining some constants:

```
const mₑ = 5.97e24
const mₘ = 7.3459e22
const G_val = 6.6743e-11
const r₁₂_val = 384400e3
const Ω = sqrt(G_val * (mₑ + mₘ)/r₁₂_val^3)
const μ₁ = G_val*mₑ
const μ₂ = G_val*mₘ
const π₁ = mₑ/(mₑ + mₘ)
const π₂ = mₘ/(mₑ + mₘ)
```

Next, the system variables (note I am introducing the `ti`

and `Di`

variables to prevent compatibility errors between the circular restricted and general three-body propagators):

```
@variables(begin
ti,
x(ti),
y(ti),
z(ti),
ẋ(ti),
ẏ(ti),
ż(ti),
r₁(ti),
r₂(ti)
end)
Di = Differential(ti)
```

The system equations:

```
earth_moon_cr_three_body_equations = [
r₁ ~ sqrt((x + π₂*r₁₂_val)^2 + y^2 + z^2),
r₂ ~ sqrt((x - π₁*r₁₂_val)^2 + y^2 + z^2),
Di(x) ~ ẋ,
Di(y) ~ ẏ,
Di(z) ~ ż,
Di(ẋ) ~ 2*Ω*ẏ + x*Ω^2 - (x + π₂*r₁₂_val)*μ₁/r₁^3 - (x - π₁*r₁₂_val)*μ₂/r₂^3,
Di(ẏ) ~ y*Ω^2 - 2*Ω*ẋ - y*μ₁/r₁^3 - y*μ₂/r₂^3,
Di(ż) ~ -z*μ₁/r₁^3 - z*μ₂/r₂^3,
]
earth_moon_cr_three_body_system = ODESystem(
earth_moon_cr_three_body_equations,
ti,
name=:earth_moon_cr_three_body_system
) |> structural_simplify
```

Defining the conditions for a lunar fly-by:

```
u₀ = Dict(
x => -4671e3,
y => -6378e3 - 200e3,
z => 0.0,
ẋ => 10.9148e3 * cos(deg2rad(19)),
ẏ => -10.9148e3 * sin(deg2rad(19)),
ż => 0.0
)
```

Finally once more, defining the problem and solving:

```
earth_moon_cr_three_body_problem = ODEProblem(
earth_moon_cr_three_body_system,
u₀,
[0.0, 3.4 * 24 * 60 * 60],
[],
jac=true
)
cr_three_body_sol = solve(earth_moon_cr_three_body_problem, Tsit5())
```

Now we can plot the result:

```
function circle(x, y, r)
θ = LinRange(0, 2*π, 500)
x .+ r*sin.(θ), y .+ r*cos.(θ)
end
cr3bp_interp = cr_three_body_sol(0.0 : 50 : 3.4 * 24 * 60 * 60)
plot(
cr3bp_interp[x] ./ 1e3, cr3bp_interp[y] ./ 1e3,
xlabel="x (km)", ylabel="y (km)",
size=(800,500),
aspect_ratio=:equal,
label=""
)
plot!(
circle(-4671, 0, 6378),
seriestype = [:shape,],
lw=0.5, c = :lightblue, fillalpha=0.5,
label=""
)
plot!(
circle(-4671 + 384400, 0, 1737.4),
seriestype = [:shape,],
lw=0.5, c = :gray, fillalpha=0.5,
label=""
)
```

Pretty sick.

You may have noticed that I did not include units with the definition of this orbit type. As with the previous types, I've tried implementing `Unitful.jl`

units into the system definition. However, this orbit type just does not play nicely with units. The first issue I encountered was:

`MethodError: *(::Unitful.Quantity{Float64, 𝐓⁻¹, Unitful.FreeUnits{(rad, s⁻¹), 𝐓⁻¹, nothing}}, ::Symbolics.Num) is ambiguous.`

I've tried fixing this issue and another issue with division as well by reading through a GitHub issue thread, which suggested to overload the multiplication operator:

```
import Base:*
*(x::Unitful.AbstractQuantity,y::Num) = Quantity(x.val*y, unit(x))
*(y::Num,x::Unitful.AbstractQuantity) = x*y
import Base:/
/(x::Unitful.AbstractQuantity,y::Num) = Quantity(x.val/y, unit(x))
/(y::Num,x::Unitful.AbstractQuantity) = y/x
```

This fixed the initial error, but then I was getting a `DimensionError`

related to the $\Omega$ variable:

`DimensionError: 5.33076e-6ẏ(t) rad s⁻¹ and 7.104250544399999e-12x(t) rad² s⁻² are not dimensionally compatible.`

Getting rid of the units from $\Omega$ causes yet another error:

`TypeError: non-boolean (Symbolics.Num) used in boolean context`

At this point I just decided to wait until `Unitful.jl`

and `ModelingToolkit.jl`

had time to update and hopefully work together better. Until then, the CR3BP propagator will not include units.

With the major orbit dynamics systems defined, my next goal is to integrate them properly into SAT. I want to create a general interface to work with the three systems and potential future ones. Here is my initial attempt at a universal orbital system format to encode the information about a specific system, as well as some constructors for a two-body system:

```
struct OrbitalSystem{T<:Number, Quant<:Number}
type::String
eqns::Vector{Equation}
system::ODESystem
problem::ODEProblem
u₀::Dict{Num, Quant}
params::Dict{Num, Quant}
tspan::Vector{T}
end
function Base.show(io::IO, system::OrbitalSystem)
out_string = """Orbital System Model: $(system.type)
Initial Conditions:
$(system.u₀)
Parameters:
$(system.params)
"""
println(out_string)
end
function TwoBodySystem(
u₀::Dict{Num, Quantity{T}},
params::Dict{Num, Quantity{T}},
tspan::Vector{T}
) where {T<:Number}
@assert valtype(u₀) == valtype(params) "Numeric values in u₀ and params must be the same type"
prob = ODEProblem(
diffeq_two_body_system,
remove_units(u₀),
tspan,
remove_units(params),
jac=true
)
return OrbitalSystem{T, Quantity{T}}(
"Two-Body System",
two_body_equations,
diffeq_two_body_system,
prob,
u₀,
params,
tspan
)
end
function TwoBodySystem(
u₀::Dict{Num, T},
params::Dict{Num, T},
tspan::Vector{T}
) where {T<:Number}
@assert valtype(u₀) == valtype(params) "Numeric values in u₀ and params must be the same type"
@warn "Warning: It is recommended to use Unitful.jl units when working with SAT"
prob = ODEProblem(
diffeq_two_body_system,
u₀,
tspan,
params,
jac=true
)
return OrbitalSystem{T, T}(
"Two-Body System",
two_body_equations,
diffeq_two_body_system,
prob,
u₀,
params,
tspan
)
end
function SolveOrbitalSystem(system::OrbitalSystem, solver::Union{DEAlgorithm,Nothing}; solver_args...)
return solve(system.problem, solver; solver_args...)
end
```

As can be seen, I am making sure that the initial values and parameter variables are a consistent datatype, the same as I have been using during development of the orbital systems. I want to enforce the use of units as well, for applying conversions and other functionality. In addition, I am using multiple dispatch to include an option to define a system without units, though this prints a warning advising against this. This `struct`

also provides potential users access to the equations, the `ODESystem`

, and `ODEProblem`

variables if they want to use those specifically.

I also want to implement a way to ensure that the `u₀`

and `params`

variables provided to the constructors are properly set, i.e.,

`u₀`

contains all the required variables (`x₁`

,`ẋ₁`

, etc.) and`params`

contains all the required parameters (`G`

,`m₁`

, etc.)If using units, also ensuring that the units are correct, i.e.

`G`

is in $\text{N} \; \text{m}^2 / \text{kg}^2$,`ẋ₁`

is in $\text{m}/\text{s}$, etc.

I think this emphasis on validation ensures that no silly mistakes are made, and the user is being careful with their inputs. It also provides reassurance that the calculations done by SAT themselves are valid.

The `SolveOrbitalSystem`

function is probably not necessary, but it just simplifies the call to the `solve`

function by removing the need for the user to specify the problem of the system themselves.

With the `OrbitalSystem`

struct, it is now pretty convenient to define and solve the two-body problem. For a simple plotting example using `Makie.jl`

:

```
two_body_system = TwoBodySystem(
two_body_example_u₀,
two_body_example_p,
two_body_example_tspan
)
two_body_sol = SolveOrbitalSystem(two_body_system, Tsit5())
fig = Figure(resolution=(1500,1500))
ax1 = Axis3(fig[1,1])
lines!(
ax1,
sol_interp[x₁], sol_interp[y₁], sol_interp[z₁],
label="Mass 1"
)
lines!(
ax1,
sol_interp[x₂], sol_interp[y₂], sol_interp[z₂],
label="Mass 2"
)
axislegend(ax1)
```

I will also write some more functions to further simplify workflows. For example, a function that automatically returns the vectors of interpolated values from the solution variable given the desired variables and a range of times.

Thanks for reading! It was fun adding more functionality to SAT. With the main orbital dynamics propagators defined I will focus more on building interactive tools that use them, as well as further refining the workflow of using the `OrbitalSystem`

objects.

Thanks for reading! Until next time.

CC BY-SA 4.0 Michal Jagodzinski. Last modified: May 29, 2023.

Website built with Franklin.jl and the Julia programming language.

Website built with Franklin.jl and the Julia programming language.